My book rating system …

I stole this idea from Em @ Pretty Lil Book Blog – for which my thanks – but I’ve also talked about it at my book club, so I decided to try and get it down on paper, especially as personal taste is really hard to quantify.

I’m a fairly hard nut to crack in that most of what I read gets 3 stars. Few books get 4 or 5 stars. I’d have to check, but I suspect 2 or 1 star(s) are handed out on an even more rare basis. Lately I’ve been thinking that the 3 star bundle are a very mixed batch and I really should do something about that but, with only 5 stars to work with, it’s tricky. As a novice writer, I find it almost impossible to hand out less than 3 stars, unless a book is truly gut-wrenchingly awful, or written by a hugely established writer to whom my review is going to do absolutely no harm.

To add a little more detail (and some visuals, you know, just ‘cos …)


To qualify for the full 5 stars, I must have found a book exceptional, truly excellent. If I’m being entirely honest, I don’t think I could give 5 stars to a book I didn’t like. To make it into this category, a book has to be near perfect in my eyes – although the emotions it causes can emcompass everything from hysterical laughter to sadness, even distress. Some examples of my 5 star-ers include the classics “Pere Goriot” & “To Kill a Mockingbird”, Man Booker winners “The Narrow Road to the Deep North” & “The Luminaries”, as well as some less expected examples such as “The Moon is A Balloon”, “World War Z: An Oral History of the Zombie Apocalypse” and “Cocktail Hour under the Tree of Forgetfulness”. A mixed bag there, I think you’ll agree.



For me to give 4 out of 5 stars would mean this is still a very good book. But, it’s possible that I didn’t like it, or found an aspect of it a trifle irritating, or it just didn’t blow me away. It’s hard to quantify always, especially as it’s also for those books which I feel deserve to be lifted out of that massive 3 star group. So in the classics category we have “Doctor Zhivago” & “The Great Gatsby”, award winners “The Shipping News”, “A Brief History of Seven Killings” and both Hilary Mantel’s Man Booker winners. But there’s also two from the Harry Potter series, a couple of Tom Clancy thrillers, one or two from favourite authors Jasper Fforde & Marian Keyes.



I give 3 out of 5 stars to books that I’ve liked and I’ve found well-written. This category can include everything from pretty decent to good. Some are lighter than others, in either subject matter or style. A few teeter on the edge of going up or down, but didn’t quite make it. Pretty much everything I’ve ever read from the pen of Dick Francis fits in here – they’re my comfort reads, Anne Tyler features regularly, as does the “Rivers of London” series. Other examples are “The Miniaturist”, “Small Island”, “The Time Traveller’s Wife”, “Murder on the Orient Express”, a couple each of Robert Harris & John Le Carré, “The Wind Up Bird Chronicle”, even Pulitzer Prizewinner “The Goldfinch”.


no 2 images

To get 2 out of 5 stars, the book has to have committed some sort of sin – be written badly, contain annoyingly obvious incorrect fact(s), be horribly trite and stereotype-laden, be disappointing offerings from good authors, or have been hugely over-hyped. Examples include two from a recent Man Booker shortlist “We are all Completely Beside Ourselves” & “To Rise Again at a Decent Hour”, bestsellers “The Alchemist” & “Girl on a Train”, as well as the earlier books from the Harry Potter series.


no giphy

To get 1 out of 5 stars, the book has had to be beyond the pale – in my opinion. Examples of this rarity are “Heart Shaped Box”, “The Secret”, later Jack Ryan offerings from Tom Clancy and “Three Cups of Tea”.

There are authors who’ve featured in multiple sectors – an extreme would be Tom Clancy who appears in every sector from 1 to 4 stars, whereas Haruki Murakami & David Mitchell only cover 3 to 5. Dick Francis stands alone as an author whose work has been steadily rated (as a 3) and to whom I return over and over again. Generally I judge on a book-by-book basis.

In general terms, my tastes tend away from detailed gore and towards nuanced emotion, away from horror and towards wit, away from action-packed scenarios and towards more character-driven work. But, I reserve the right to change my mind when I read something I really like!

How about you all out there in reader land? What is your rating system? Need to disagree with me over any of my examples?

© Debra Carey, 2017



7 thoughts on “My book rating system …

Add yours

  1. I don’t give my books ratings but like you I find that there are authors whose output is variable. I can almost count on the fingers of one hand the Agatha Christies that I like enough to make an effort to re-read. To me the jewel in her crown is The Moving Finger. All Dorothy L. Sayers is (would be!) five star. Another author on a spectrum is Terry Pratchett; although most of his are top class one or two of the earlier Discworld drop down to meh. I have never been able to finish a Charles Dickens book, except Christmas Carol. A few books, which I shall not name here, are, in the classic phrase, not to be lightly tossed aside, but thrown with force! 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Oooooooooo but I have to knowwwwwww.
    I’ve never heard that phrase before, but I simply adore it and will be using it forthwith 😀

    I don’t know that Agatha Christie. I’m giving you *that* look, for I’m going to have to add it to the list if not the pile …

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Moving Finger is good. I like Partners in Crime,where she tries out different crime writers’ styles in a series of connected short stories. Changing genre, I think most of Lois McMaster Bujold’s Vorkosiverse is 4 or 5; of the 5 Gods’ World Curse of Chalion is definitely 5*.

    Liked by 2 people

  4. @breakerofthings – I’ve only just spotted your comment, so my apols for late response. Nevertheless, I see that you have *gratuitously* added to my TBR! But as you’ve mentioned the Lois McMaster Bujold before and as my lack of Agatha Christie reading does seem somewhat lax, I’ll forgive you!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

A Website.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: